Warrior Cats: The Four Clans

yeah, I wouldnt ask you to prove it, thats true, maybe it was just timing. A lot of times timing in books and movies are like unrealistic. Like in Firestars Quest, Firestar called Sandstorm his mate throughout the book, yet they didnt have kits until the end, after they resolved their problems. And Sandstorm was fighting the rats, there was no mention of her having kits, so it could just be timing that supported the scene, but there still is a high chance of that happening, theres so many books I cant even remember some things anymore, like it's hard to remember Firestar was once Rusty, and as a kittypet, I could never imagine him finding any way to lose a life, even if every cat, not just leaders, had nine. :P He'd live until he was really, really old, unless there was coyotes or something that hurt him around his home. But in the wild, so many things could hurt him.